Ingredient

mushrooms

The fruiting body of various fungi, prized for a savory, umami-rich flavor that deepens with cooking; sauteed, roasted, or simmered into sauces and soups. They're mostly water by weight, which is the single fact that governs how they cook -- crowd them in the pan and they steam instead of browning.

Buying guidance

Choose mushrooms that are dry and firm with a fresh earthy smell; reject anything slimy, in wet packaging, or with dark, sunken spots. Slightly open gills on cremini or portobello are normal, not a sign of spoilage -- a strong ammonia smell and collapsing, wet flesh are the real red flags. Cook them in a wide, uncrowded pan over high heat: mushrooms release a lot of water as they heat, and that water has to evaporate before any browning starts.

Substitutions

  • Cremini for button, or the reverse -- nearly interchangeable by weight, cremini a bit deeper in flavor.
  • Portobello -- much larger and meatier, better sliced thick as a standalone piece than diced into a sauce.
  • Dried shiitake, rehydrated -- far more concentrated flavor; strain and save the soaking liquid, which carries a lot of the mushroom flavor itself.

Tips & common mistakes

Washing them is fine, but soaking them or rinsing well ahead of time adds moisture that speeds up sliminess -- wipe or rinse briefly right before cooking instead.

Storage

Move them out of sealed store packaging and into a paper bag once home -- plastic traps moisture against them and they turn slimy within days, while a paper bag lets that moisture escape. They're more perishable than firmer vegetables even under good conditions, and raw mushrooms turn watery and rubbery if frozen, though cooked ones freeze acceptably.

More specific

Used in 11 recipes